Refreshing, made with whole foods, a little booze and a touch of sugar, this white rum cocktail is my best Piña Colada recipe! You won’t believe how easy this frozen tropical cocktail is to whip up.

How I Discovered The Best Piña Colada Recipe

Before we get to my this classic sipper, a little back story. Traveling has a way with vivid reminders of how we’re interconnected with people, land and the wild things. Whether it’s simply traveling 100 miles away from home or across the globe, I’m always interested in culture, food and ecology and how these things interact on a local and global scale. Food is interesting to me especially from the standpoint of farming practices.

While traveling in Costa Rica we passed miles and miles of monocultured pineapple. I’d never seen so many pineapples. While beautiful pineapple plants were perfectly planted in symmetrical rows, the land itself looked sterile. No more forests, not a weed in sight…

Our guide shared that Costa Rica is one of the top exporters of pineapples worldwide, currently. He also explained one pineapple plant takes over a year to produce one pineapple fruit when grown organically. However, multinational corporations conventionally grow a pineapple in six months by applying agrochemicals. These production practices allow for increased crop yields in a shorter period of time.

That made me think of the conventional pineapple BOGO I saw on special at the store last week. What price are we willing to pay in terms of human and environmental costs for cheap pineapple? (insert x for so many other crops)

There’re great things going for Costa Rica – a few examples I learned

an end to single use plastics in 2020 – the one souvenir I brought back from Costa Rica is in the cocktail images – bamboo straws! Native to Costa Rica, compostable and sustainable
whose goal is to be a carbon-neutral country
no mass highway systems because it would devastate the ecosystem, home to rich biodiversity which fuels their ecotourism economy
they just marked their 70th anniversary since abolishing their military to instead further invest in the education and welness of its people
provides universal welness care to its citizens and permanent residents

But as progressive as Costa Rica is, they struggle with issues as any nation does. I couldn’t help but think about how like the US, they too have people living in the margins. Workers, some immigrants, endure harsh working conditions, low wages, and exposure to toxic chemicals to put food on our tables. And as a consumer, I have a choice every time I spend a dollar at the store or opt to buy through community-supported agriculture or at the farmers market.

Because every dollar I spend on food is a vote for farming practices, sustainable or not. Pineapple is simply one example.

So, I avoid the BOGO and enjoy the single succulent pineapple that tastes sweeter, is slightly more expensive and juicier anyway. If I can’t find a fresh organically grown pineapple, I go without and look for canned (organic) or opt for locally grown fruit when in season.

Piña Colada Ingredients

For fresh, homemade tropical flavor, skip the pre mixed variety! Who woulda’ thought? A Piña Colada Recipe with coconut milk (!!). This tropical drink is so easy to whip up with just a few ingredients (see recipe card below for details):

Pineapple – for the best Pina Colada of your life, look for organic pineapple, fresh when in season! The texture and flavor are worth the effort. If out of season, look for organic canned and juice pineapple. Only one of the three stores I shop at carry organic canned, so it can be hard to find unless purchased online. I like Native Forest for chunks and crushed pineapple.
Pineapple Juice – I like Lakewood brand for juice. If making one batch, simply use the juice in the canned pineapple.
Coconut Cream – coconut creme or cream of coconut, I use a can of full fat coconut milk (organic!), refrigerated, then I scoop out the solid coconut cream needed for the recipe.
White Rum – I like Bacardi.
Sugar – just a pinch – adjust depending how sweet your pineapple is.

How to Make a Tropical Classic

It’s super simple to make and tastes so fresh. Grab your blender and let’s whip this adult beverage up!

First, into a high speed blender, add the pineapple, pineapple juice, coconut cream, white rum, sugar and ice.
Next, give the ingredients a whirl, until you have a velvety-smooth texture.
Last, taste for sugar adjustment and add more if desired. Whirl again!

Pour into low ball or chilled hurricane glass and garnish with fresh pineapple and, for a little fun, a paper umbrella.

Pro Tips

If carving a fresh pineapple and you’re into smoothies, don’t throw out the core! It blitzes up beautifully in a high speed blender. Toss it in the freezer until ready to use.
For an extra frosty homemade Pina Colada delight, freeze the pineapple chunks before blending.
Because the sweetness of pineapple varies, taste before adding sugar to your homemade Pina Colada, then adjust to taste.
Make a Virgin Pina Colada! Fabulous as mocktails, simply leave the rum out and add more pineapple and/or coconut cream!

More Refreshing White Rum Cocktail Recipes to Love

Save Recipe Print Recipe

Fresh Pina Colada Recipe

Prep Time:5

Total Time:5

Servings:2 - 3 Servings

Calories:441kcal

Author:Traci York

A creamy, fresh summertime cocktail. Quick and simple to whip up with fresh, frozen or canned pineapple. vegan + gluten free

Ingredients

▢ 1 1/2 C Whole Pineapple Chunks* 245g (if using canned chunks - from a whole pineapple see notes)
▢ 1/4 C Pineapple Juice 48g
▢ 2 Tbs Coconut Cream** from a can of full fat coconut milk - see note
▢ 3 oz White Rum 70g - for two servings (4 1/2 oz (105g) for three) see notes
▢ 1 Tbs Organic Cane Sugar adjust to taste - See Note
▢ 3 C Ice 320 g

Garnish:

▢ Fresh Pineapple Wedges

Instructions

In a high speed blender, add the pineapple chunks, juice, coconut creme, rum, sugar and ice. Blend on high speed until the mixture is smooth yet still icy cold. Taste for sugar adjustment if needed.
Pour into serving glasses and garnish with fresh pineapple.

Notes

Serving size: If serving in low ball glasses, I can get three servings out of this batch. If serving in a high ball, two servings. Adjust the rum according to serving size.

Fresh Pina Coladas are fabulous as mocktails. Simply leave the rum out and add a few more chunks of pineapple and/or one tablespoon of coconut cream!

*If using fresh cut pineapple chunks measure out almost two cups(245g). Because the chunks are hand cut, rather from a machine like canned, they will be odd shaped and probably larger in size. **For the coconut creme, I use a can of full fat coconut milk, refrigerated, then I scoop out the solid coconut cream needed for the recipe. ***The amount of added sugar can be adjusted up or down depending on the sweetness of the pineapple. Sometimes I add more, sometimes less.

Nutrition is provided as a courtesy and is an estimate. If this information is important to you, please have it verified independently.

Made It? Leave a comment below! The most helpful comment may include recipe rating, feedback, any modifications and/or helping other commenters. On Instagram? Take a snap of your make and share, tagging @VanillaAndBean #VanillaAndBean!

14 comments